The Deliberate Protestant
A family friend asked me to comment on an article entitled “The Accidental Catholic”, which was recently posted on the Called to Communion blog (run by converts to Roman Catholicism from Reformed churches). Below are my comments (edited and slightly expanded).
The author’s basic argument can be summarized simply as follows:
- If Sola Scriptura were correct and the Protestant churches were led by the Holy Spirit, there wouldn’t be many doctrinal disagreements between Protestant churches.
- But there are many doctrinal disagreements between Protestant churches.
- Therefore, it can’t be the case that Sola Scriptura is correct and the Protestant churches are led by the Holy Spirit.
The most serious problem with the argument is that there’s no good reason to accept the first premise. Here are some reasons why, along with some other related comments:
…
The Deliberate Protestant Read More »