I’ve uploaded a revised version of my paper “Calvinism and the First Sin” (see this earlier post for context). I think it’s improved in several ways, thanks to constructively critical feedback from a number of folk (see final footnote for credits). The main changes:
- A brief explanation of why I address problems not unique to the first sin. (p. 5)
- A stronger response to the charge that Calvinism makes God culpable for human sin. (pp. 15-17)
- A stronger response to the difficulty of explaining why (given compatibilism) unfallen Adam would freely choose to sin. In particular, I’ve added a section on how contemporary analyses of akrasia could shed some light on the issue. (pp. 20-24)
- The “luck objection” to libertarian free will has been brought forward to section 2.
- I cut out the objection to libertarian free will based on the Principle of Sufficient Reason. Dan Johnson pointed out a problem with the argument: as it stands, it relies on a version of the PSR which appears to commit one to necessitarianism. I still think the PSR raises more problems for libertarianism than compatibilism, but it would take me too far afield to get into that in this paper, and the main argument of the paper stands (or falls!) without it.
- What I formerly called “The Arminian Account” I now call “The Simple Foreknowledge Account” (see footnote 52 for explanation).
Please note again that the online preprint version will be removed once the book is published and should not be quoted or cited in place of the published version.
1 thought on “Calvinism and the First Sin (Again)”
Pingback: Early January 2014 Van Tillian Links | The Domain for Truth
Comments are closed.